The Academic Friends of Israel


Vol.10 No 4                                                                                     31 May 2011

UCU condemned as “institutionally anti-Semitic”

The University and College Union (UCU), which represents more than 120,000 University staff, used its annual gathering in Harrogate over the Bank Holiday weekend to disassociate itself from EUMC working definition of antisemitism which is used by law enforcement agencies all over the world.  

The UCU, the leading trade union partner of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, made this move in an attempt to redefine anti Semitism. They didn't just reject parts of the definition or propose changes to it instead they decided never to use it again whether educating members or dealing with internal complaints of antisemitism.   

I was the only Jewish delegate at Congress who was willing to speak against the motion. The motion was carried overwhelmingly as only four people including myself voted against it. I spoke in complete silence with no reaction at all from the audience, this is what I said: 

I, a Jewish member of this union, am telling you, that I feel an antisemitic mood in this union and even in this room.

 I would feel your refusal to engage with the EUMC definition of antisemitism, if you pass this motion, as a racist act. 

Many Jews have resigned from this union citing their experience of antisemitsim. 

Only yesterday a delegate here said: "they are an expansionist people”. It is difficult to think that the people in question are anything other than the Jews. 

You may disagree with me. 

 You may disagree with all the other Jewish members who have said similar things. 

You may think we are mistaken. 

But you have a duty to listen seriously.

Instead of being listened to, I am routinely told that anyone who raises the issue of antisemitism is doing so in bad faith. 

Congress, Imagine how it feels when you say that you are experiencing racism, and your union responds: "Stop lying, stop trying to play the antisemitism card." 

You, a group of mainly white, non-Jewish trade unionists, do not have the right to tell me, a Jew, what feels like antisemitism and what does not.

Macpherson tells us that when somebody says they have been a victim of racism, then institutions should begin by believing them.

This motion mandates the union to do the opposite. Until this union takes complaints of antisemitsim seriously the UCU will continue to be labelled as an institutionally antisemitic organisation. 

It’s true that anti-Zionist Jews may perceive things differently.  But the overwhelming majority of Jews feel that there is something wrong in this union.

They understand that it is legitimate to criticise Israel in a way that is, quoting from the definition, “similar to that levelled to any other country" but they make a distinction between criticism and the kind of demonisation that is considered acceptable in this union. 

The union also adopted a resolution which ignored the legal advice that the UCU received in 2007 which made it clear that distributing and promoting a call for the academic and cultural boycott of Israel is in breach of discrimination and equality legislation and also outside the aims and objects of the union. 

 Ronnie Fraser


The Academic Friends of Israel 

Links to Documents:

Academic Friends of Israel press release which condemns the UCU for adopting an illegal resolution - 29 May 2011  

Academic Friends of Israel press release which describes the UCU as “institutionally anti-Semitic” -30 May 2011 

Here is   Engage's live blog from the debate on antisemitism.

Here is  Engage's live blog from the debate on boycotting Israel.

Here is  the response by Jewish Students to their lecturers.

Here is the letter sent by leaders of Jewish communal organisations to the UCU General Secretary before the debate -25May 2011.

Here is the response by Trevor Philips, The Chair of the Equalities and Human Rights Commission to the Jewish Communal organisations letter (pdf).David Hirsh on the EUMC motion

Here is a piece by the CST on the UCU, EUMC, antisemitism and anti-Zionism

Here is The Politics of Defining Racism: The Case of Anti-Semitism in the University and College Union by Ben Gidley

UCU Congress motion 70 - EUMC working definition of anti-Semitism 

 UCU motion 36 - Threats to academic freedom in Israel and Palestine 

Patron: The Chief Rabbi, Sir Jonathan Sacks

Advisory Board:  Dr Manfred Gerstenfeld - Chairman of the Board of Fellows, Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.

Vivian Wineman - President of the Board of Deputies of British Jews

Amir Lev

John D A Levy - Director of the Academic Study Group on Israel and the Middle East

Andrew R. Marks, M.D. - Columbia University, USA

Professor Leslie Wagner CBE

Rt Hon Lord Young of Graffham

The Academic Friends of Israel Ltd is limited by guarantee and registered in England No 5297417.